I ain't one of the Cosbies/I didn't go to Trey Hillman
Three years ago, a decision was made that probably altered the futures of fivefour sports franchises and five men.
October 4, 2006Buck Showalter is fired by the Texas Rangers as manager.
November 6, 2006The Texas Rangers replace Showalter with Oakland A's third-base coach Ron Washington.
Other candidates were former Rangers catcher John Russell, bench coach Don Wakamatsu, New York Mets third-base coach Manny Acta and Nippon Ham Fighters manager Trey Hillman.
Washington's hire is a bit of a letdown. Many were clamoring for Hillman, a alum of The University of Texas at Arlington, who had cut his teeth on baseball with the Rangers. I think Russell was the second choice, being a former player.
November 14, 2006The Washington Nationals hire Acta as manager.
October 19, 2007The Kansas City Royals hire Hillman as manager.
November 5, 2007The Pittsburgh Pirates hire former Major Leaguer John Russell as manager.
November 19, 2008The Seattle Mariners name Wakamatsu manager.
July 13, 2009The Nationals fire Acta.
October 25, 2009The Cleveland Indians name Acta manager.
May 13, 2010The Kansas City Royals fire Hillman as manager.
In their respective tenures as Major-League managers, here's how the records have turned out:
| Managing Records |
| Washington | 261-260 |
| Wakamatsu | 98-98 |
| Hillman | 142-207 |
| Russell | 143-214 |
| Acta | 171-271 |
Now, it is impossible to project how good these five guys are as managers or baseball men.
Before they were hired, only one had managing experience, and that was Hillman in Japan.
I'd like to think that if the Rangers hired Hillman or Russell, their records as managers would be over .500 like Washington's.
Of the franchises discussed (Washington, Texas, Seattle, Cleveland, Kansas City), the Rangers may be the best. Meaning, in the past, they've had some money to work with. They've had the luxury of having a good front office that has helped build a really good farm system perpetually providing young players of high quality to the big-league team.
I can not attest this is the same for those other franchises.
Seattle may be the exception. They've spent a lot of money to get good and despite an 85-win season last year, their anemic offense is sinking them this season.
Otherwise, we could expect Washington to have gone to Kansas City and had as much success as Hillman did.
But we'll never know. Maybe only Washington could have helped get this team to play harder for 162 games.
Hillman deserved the ax. Maybe. Kansas City doesn't exactly put the best product on the field. But there's still talent there. Other managers have won with less.
Jeff Passan wrote an article at Yahoo! about the epiphany for Royals management as the Rangers swept the Royals in four games.
There was Hillman docking Yuniesky Betancourt money for dropping a pop fly. There was another moment of Josh Hamilton taking second base without tagging up ... and no one, including the managers, not noticing.
Wash wouldn't dock a player money for dropping a pop fly. He'd, instead, go out the next day four hours before the game and work on technique, concentration, footwork and positioning with that player.
Wash may screw up the bullpen. But I don't think he'd miss an opponent not tagging up.
A team managed by Ron Washington wouldn't allow a four-game sweep.
Hillman will land on his feet in a better situation. As will all these guys until franchises discontinue putting faith in them. For the time being, these guys are all kind of tied together.
Labels: Firings, Hirings, Rangers, Ron Washington